"I think our previous Group RRSP advisor visited our offices and plan members once in 1997. I have lost count the number of times the DV Associates' advisor has visited and met each plan member through 2002 and into 2003."
Trudy Cornwell, Controller
L&M Precision Products
Case Study
Situation
L&M Precision Products Limited is a specialty
manufacturer of metal products with approximately 100 employees. In 1991 the company
terminated its registered pension plan and replaced it with a Group RRSP/DPSP arrangement.
Originally, the Group RRSP/DPSP was managed by a life insurance company. In 1997
a large downtown brokerage firm was appointed as advisor and manager and all accounts
were transferred to Mackenzie Financial and MRS Trust. The brokerage firm advisor
made various changes in the investments of some of the accounts over the next 5
years usually explaining and discussing the changes with the individual plan members
over the telephone.
Challenge
Unknown to the management of L&M Precision Products
many of the employees, and, of course, a number of those approaching the end of
their working careers, were very anxious about their savings in the Group RRSP and
DPSP. After 5 years of inattention there was an under-current of discontent. The
employees needed individual consultation to firstly, adjust their investment program
to their circumstances and risk profile and to demonstrate and explain to them actual
investment progress and expected future progress. And secondly, for those approaching
retirement specific action was needed to deal with the technicalities of changing
to RRIFs and LRIFs.
Solution
Immediately upon appointment in June 2002, DV
Associates retrieved historical data on all plan member accounts and prepared individual
statements of all contributions and redemptions since 1997. In addition DVA calculated
actual individual account rates of return over the 5 year period to June 30, 2002.
The DV Associates' advisor then met with each
plan member separately and (1) reviewed all transactions that had taken place since
1997 to ensure that each plan member was satisfied that all deposits and other transactions
were correct, and (2) examined and explained the actual investment results for the
plan member's own accounts. In this latter case the explanation in many cases corrected
misconceptions as to overall investment returns. Most plan members were under the
impression that their accounts had suffered significant losses. However, in most
cases, adjusting for deposits and withdrawals, if any, most accounts had actually
ended up with very small losses or very small gains over the 1997 to 2002 period.
Discussing these investment results with the
plan members helped greatly in calming the atmosphere. Nevertheless, it was clear
that the members' accounts could have been managed more closely. Changes were made
to the investment program of most members based on their circumstances and investment
risk tolerance profile.
An important aspect of this process was to explain
the cost structure of the Group RRSP/DPSP and the value of the Company's DPSP contributions
to each member's account each year. Further it was made clear that each member's
investment program was being adjusted to provide more flexibility for future changes.
Each member now has the ability to ask the DV
Associates' advisor questions either on his many visits to the L&M Precision offices
or on the telephone. Each calendar quarter DVA prepares a statement for each member
summarizing the holdings and actual individual rates of return for each member's
accounts.
Every month DVA prepares special tracking charts
of each investment fund used in all member investment programs with the purpose
of monitoring investment results and, where appropriate suggesting changes. Such
changes would only be made if there are clear reasons to do so. At least once each
year meetings are held with the members to discuss progress and possible changes
to the investment program.